Della and Mathilde - A Comparative Study

387 Words2 Pages
The Necklace and The Gift of The Magi are two intriguing stories. The Necklace tells the tale of Matildhe, a young lady who longs for what she cannot have. The Gift of The Magi tells the tale of Della, a giving and loving wife. Matildhe and Della are very different women, and yet their situations share certain similarities. A reader might describe Matildhe Loisel as selfish. She's always dreamt of attending elegant dinners and owning a fancy house. Matildhe believed that she deserved more in life. When a chance presented itself for Matildhe to have a glimpse of a rich woman's life, she hesitated only because she had nothing suitable to wear. Her main objective was to be the prettiest woman going to the party. She used her husband's rifle money to buy a dress and borrowed her friend's fake diamond necklace. Unfortunately, Matildhe lost the necklace and reluctantly replaced it. Ironically, she did not know the necklace was a fake and replaced it with a real one. Unlike Matildhe, Della was caring and considerate. She had less money, but didn't selfishly complain. She was content with the way she lived. All Della wanted was enough money to buy her husband a nice watch chain for Christmas. In order to collect the money needed for the chain, she selflessly sold her long, beautiful hair. Della's sacrifice is made even greater because she could no longer use her husband's gift for her, a comb for her once beautiful, long hair. Any attentive reader would notice these differences. They would also notice the similarities in the characters and their situations. Matildhe and Della were equally beautiful wives who longed for more money. They lived low-middle class lives and sought after what they could not afford. The women each purchased an item with ironic consequences. In order to purchase the necklace and watch chain, Matildhe and Della both had to make sacrifices.

More about Della and Mathilde - A Comparative Study

Open Document