Comparing and Contrasting a Barred Owl and the History Teacher

462 Words2 Pages
In the poem A Barred Owl by Richard Wilbur, the author explains that an adult protects a child from the truth by telling her in lines 3-6 that she only heard an owl asking her a harmless question “Who cooks for you”. In the poem The History Teacher by Billy Collins, Mr. Collins depicts a school teacher who chooses to hide the truth of the world's past history from his students to protect their innocence. Both authors have trusted figures in the children’s lives who both have the same concept of lying and misleading the children into believing something that is false to in order to “protect” the child's innocence and for the sake of the adult's peace of mind. In the Barred Owl, the parents telling the child that the bird is asking her simple questions that shouldn’t make her scared is an example of personification (the Owl talking) and it also symbolizes a lack of foresight that is an effort to protect their daughter, but they have given her an unrealistic outlook on the world that can create its own future negative effects in the child's life. The poem The History Teacher while lacking personification it shares the same concept of symbolism in the same way, the teacher hides and shelters his students from the truth about history by telling his students made up pleasant events rather than cold hard facts of history to protect their innocence. But like the parents of the A Barred Owl, the teacher has no thought for his student's future of blindness, so he is blind to what the results of his actions and how his students that he is trying to keep pure of mind are displaying and preforming the same evil that he neglected to teach them. These poems differ in that Wilbur’s poem has an obvious childlike rhythm made by the fact that it is a couplet poem. The poem by Mr. Collins has a rhythm that is guided by the structure in which it is written rather than a
Open Document