Is Mary Barnett Guilty Or Innocent

538 Words3 Pages
Justice will always prevail. Everybody is innocent until proven guilty. If proven guilty then each person is held accountable for their own actions. No matter what the circumstances are, each person should take responsibility for their mistakes. In the case of Mary Barnett, the mother of six months old Allison left her child alone and unattended while she was gone to San Francisco. When Mary Barnett return after a week she found the baby dead; an autopsy was performed on Allison only to find out that the baby had died from dehydration. According to the police Ms. Barnett knew the baby would die within a day or two. As a result, Mary Barnett is guilty and should be accountable for her actions, therefore she should be punished. I don’t think Mary Barnett is ill because she was aware of what she was doing and she knew what her consequences were. On the contrary, there is other ways she could of a handle this problem for example, she could have paid a family/neighbor to watch the baby…show more content…
Bloom stated that Mary Barnett suffered from postpartum depression, a syndrome that affects many women after the birth of their children. There are many women that have this depression and have learned to take control it. Therefore Mary had plenty of other options to seek psychiatric help, but she chose otherwise. In my opinion I think Mary is a selfish woman because she only thought for herself when she left her daughter alone. In addition, Officer Mitchell was also a witness and he stated that Mary was aware of her own actions. Mary lied to the officer by telling him firstly, that she had left the baby with a babysitter, and then secondly by saying she couldn’t find someone to watch Alison so she left her alone. In my opinion, when a person is lying it’s because he/she realizes that what they did was wrong and they feel guilty for what they have done. Dr. Bloom and Officer Mitchell are creditable for this case because their statements were based on

More about Is Mary Barnett Guilty Or Innocent

Open Document