What Arguments Might Be Given Against a Democratic System of Government? Can Democracy Be Defended Against These Arguments?

2495 Words10 Pages
3. What arguments might be given against a democratic system of government? Can democracy be defended against these arguments? Democracy is widely sought after by many countries nowadays that even developing countries like Myanmar has started their democracy movement led by Aung San Suu Kyi for political reform. However, we might ask, what democracy does the modern society often fight for? Are there any critics on this kind of system of government? Can democracy be defended against these arguments? In modern sense, democracy can be defined as “a system of governance in which rulers are held accountable for their actions in the public realm by citizens, acting indirectly through the competition and cooperation of their elected representatives.” (Schmitter and Karl 1991, 76) It is also “a mode of decision-making about collectively binding rules and policies over which the people exercise control” (Beetham 1993: 55). In other words, democracy requires political equality that the people have equal political influence which can be actualized through universal suffrage under the principle of ‘one person, one vote’. This implies the “principle of majority rule [that] the will of the majority…overrides the will of the minority. (Heywood 2002: 87). Another important component of democracy is the accountability of the government that it is responsible to answer the people’s will through cooperating and competing with other representatives as their political power is given by the people. However, people may doubt this system of government due to 1) inadequacy of voters, 2) existence of tyranny of the majority, 3) democratic overload, 4) administrative inefficiency and the 5) mob rule resulted. These arguments against and counterarguments for democracy will be explained as follows. Inadequacy of voters Firstly, many critics of democracy argue that ‘the people’,

More about What Arguments Might Be Given Against a Democratic System of Government? Can Democracy Be Defended Against These Arguments?

Open Document