Sauvain's Representation 3: A Scene Analysis: America In Vietnam

688 Words3 Pages
Introduction Representation 1 is a text extract from a GCSE textbook written by Sauvain and published in 1997. While representation 3 is a cartoon that gives insight into anti-war protests, it was created by John Fischetti and published during the Vietnam War. On the other hand, representation 2 is an extract from a book ‘America in Vietnam’ which was written by Guenter Lewy and was published in 1978. As historians, it is important to decide which representation best helps understand the way in which the people in the USA reacted to the Vietnam War. To help decide which is the best, three criteria could be used which is comprehensiveness, objectivity and accuracy to evaluate the representations. COMPREHENSIVENESS When looking at comprehensiveness we can see that representation 1 provides a large overview on the anti-war movement. It mentions a wide variety of protestors, from draft-dodgers to students and even Veterans…show more content…
This is mainly due to the purpose of the representation, which is to inform based on factual detail and not to give out a message meaning the representation is free of Phillip Sauvain’s opinion. However, the text extract does not comment on supporters of the war although this could possibly be referred to in other sections of the book. Representation 3 being a cartoon fully supports the cartoonist anti-war point of view and, by that measure cannot be objective. The purpose of the cartoon is to give out a message and to provoke debate and John Fischetti does this by satirising the anti-war movement and stereotyping the characters. He also makes a conscious decision about what information to include and what to leave out in order to support his point of view and the anti-war message the representation is trying to give out. Representation 2 however is biased and does not give any factual information and due to this it cannot be

More about Sauvain's Representation 3: A Scene Analysis: America In Vietnam

Open Document